Making Magic: Religion, Magic, and Science in the Modern World Styers, Randall

Styers presents a dense, theoretical argument that may frustrate readers seeking practical magical instruction or historical narratives. This is not a guide for practitioners but a critical analysis of academic discourse. Those expecting a straightforward history of occult practices will find little here, as the focus remains strictly on the sociological utility of the term. However, for those willing to engage with complex meta-theoretical discussions about how Western society polices the boundary between reason and superstition, this text offers a sharp, unmasking perspective on the very foundations of modern cultural identity.

Readers interested in the philosophical underpinnings of modern thought will find this book indispensable for understanding how 'magic' functions as a critical counterpoint to Western rationality. It is ideal for scholars in religious studies who wish to deconstruct the vague but powerful definitions used by academia to reinforce norms of piety and social order. By revealing magic as a deliberate mechanism rather than a failed definition, Styers offers a profound lens through which to view modern identity formation, appealing to those who enjoy rigorous intellectual exploration of how societies define themselves against constructed 'others.'

Magic as Academic Tool

Styers demonstrates that rather than being an intrinsic phenomenon, "magic" functions as a conceptual device within academia. It helps scholars demarcate the boundaries between what they classify as legitimate religion and rational science, often positioning magic as a primitive or non-modern counterpart to these established categories, thus facilitating disciplinary self-definition.

Constructing Modern Identity

The book argues that the persistent scholarly engagement with "magic" is deeply intertwined with the Western endeavor to establish and maintain specific ideals of modernity. By framing magic as irrational or deviant, society reinforces its preferred norms of instrumental rationality, industriousness, conventional gender roles, and controlled desire, solidifying a particular modern self-image.

The Power of Alterity

Styers highlights how the concept of magic acts as a powerful signifier of "otherness." It is deployed to designate forms of deviance or difference against which dominant Western notions of appropriate religious practice, scientific thought, and social relations are clearly distinguished. This process of "othering" reinforces what is considered normal and acceptable within modern frameworks.

“The persistent scholarly engagement with 'magic,' despite its stubbornly amorphous nature, reveals less about an inherent, universal phenomenon and more about the discursive needs of the disciplines themselves.”

“By consistently positioning 'magic' as the antithesis of modern scientific rigor and appropriate religious piety, Western thought has effectively forged a conceptual mirror, reflecting its own desired self-image.”

🏛 Books from this publisher Oxford University Press