Unruly Spirits: The Science of Psychic Phenomena in Modern France by Brower, M Brady

Unruly Spirits: The Science of Psychic Phenomena in Modern France — photo 1

Occult Philosophy

Unruly Spirits: The Science of Psychic Phenomena in Modern France

Name: Unruly Spirits: The Science of Psychic Phenomena in Modern France
Price: 110.00 USD
Availability: OutOfStock
Rating: 4.6 (2 reviews)
Author: Brower, M Brady
ISBN: 9780252035647

Brower, M Brady

Reader rating

4.6

(1 reviews) 55 sold

$110.00

Editorial score How we rate

Availability to be confirmed

This edition can be ordered. No arrival date is confirmed.

📚 ABOUT THE BOOK

When scientific rigor met the ethereal unknown, what truths emerged from fin-de-siècle France?

M. Brady Brower's compelling work explores how French science grappled with purported psychic phenomena like séances and telepathy during Sigmund Freud's era. It reveals an intellectual crisis that ultimately paved the way for psychoanalysis in France. Brower meticulously traces how psychical research, initially dismissed, became a legitimate scientific pursuit, driven partly by the Third Republic's need to manage popular democracy. The book details how prominent physicists and psychologists engaged with these enigmatic occurrences, until the inherent unmeasurability of trust and interpersonal dynamics stalled their investigations by the 1920s.

Key themes

Science Meets the Supernatural Origins of French Psychoanalysis Politics of Belief and Inquiry

Historical context

This work situates itself within the intellectual history of fin-de-siècle France, exploring the intersection of scientific rigor and the ethereal unknown during the era of Sigmund Freud. It examines how psychical research evolved from dismissal to legitimacy amid the Third Republic's political landscape.

Brower, M Brady

📚 all books by this author (2) →

Difficulty

●●● Demanding

Fans will love it

Sigmund Freud · Historians of Science · Scholars of Psychoanalysis · Readers interested in Fin-de-Siècle Culture

🕯️ Occult Philosophy

🏛 University of Illinois Press 📅 2010 📖 232 pages 📔 Hardcover 📐 Hardcover ISBN: 9780252035647

Fun fact

Brower's *Unruly Spirits* is a meticulously researched journey, illuminating the complex interplay between science, spirituality, and politics in fin-de-siècle France. It excels at intellectual history, showing how psychic inquiry reshaped scientific thought. Those seeking a purely experiential guide to mediumship or definitive scientific pronouncements on psychic abilities might find it less direct. It stands as a vital contribution to understanding psychology's pre-history and the evolving boundaries of scientific inquiry.

📝 Description: Unruly Spirits: The Science of Psychic Phenomena in Modern France

Unruly Spirits connects the study of séances, telepathy, telekinesis, materializations, and other parapsychic phenomena in France during the age of Sigmund Freud to an epistemological crisis that would eventually yield the French adoption of psychoanalysis. Skillfully navigating experiments conducted by nineteenth-century French psychical researchers and the wide-ranging debates that surrounded their work, M. Brady Brower situates the institutional development of psychical research at the intersection of popular faith and the emergent discipline of psychology. Brower shows how spiritualist mediums were ignored by French academic scientists for nearly three decades. Only after the ideologues of the Third Republic turned to science to address what they took to be the excess of popular democracy would the marvels of mediumism begin to emerge as legitimate objects of scientific inquiry. Taken up by the most prominent physicists, physiologists, and psychologists of the last decades of the nineteenth century, psychical research would eventually stall in the 1920s as researchers struggled to come to terms with interpersonal phenomena (such as trust and good faith) that could not be measured within the framework of their experimental methods. In characterizing psychical research as something other than a mere echo of popular spirituality or an anomaly among the sciences, Brower argues that the questions surrounding mediums served to sustain the scientific project by forestalling the establishment of a closed and complete system of knowledge. By acknowledging persistent doubt about the intentions of its participants, psychical research would result in the realization of a subjectivity that was essentially indeterminate and would thus clear the way for the French reception of psychoanalysis and the Freudian unconscious and its more comprehensive account of subjective uncertainty.

💎 Expert review

“

💎

Esoterica Books editorial team

Occult literature desk

Brower delivers a dense, academic exploration of French psychical research that demands patience from its audience. While intellectually stimulating for specialists in history of science or psychoanalytic studies, it may frustrate casual readers seeking narrative flair or accessible explanations of occult practices. The focus on the political and scientific mechanisms behind these investigations renders it dry for those expecting mystical revelations. It is strictly for those interested in the institutionalization of knowledge rather than the phenomena themselves. Do not expect light reading; this is a scholarly dissection of an intellectual crisis, suitable only for dedicated researchers willing to engage with complex historical dynamics.

✓ EDITOR'S REVIEW

📖 Why choose it

📖

Why this book is worth reading

This book is essential for scholars and enthusiasts who wish to understand the complex origins of French psychoanalysis. Readers interested in how scientific inquiry intersects with the paranormal will find Brower’s meticulous tracing of psychical research captivating. It offers a unique perspective on how prominent physicists and psychologists navigated the unmeasurable dynamics of trust during séances. By revealing an intellectual crisis that shaped modern thought, it provides deep insight into the Third Republic's efforts to manage popular democracy through science. Those fascinated by the historical validity of psychic phenomena will appreciate this rigorous examination of how the ethereal was attempted to be quantified.

⭐ Reader reviews

The starting rating comes from the team Esoterica Books —

⭐ Esoterica editorial review Editorial rating 4.7/5

★★★★★

If you're fascinated by the history of psychology, the intersection of science and spirituality, or the intellectual climate of fin-de-siècle France, this book offers profound insights. It's for readers who appreciate meticulous historical scholarship on the evolving understanding of the human mind.

Reader rating

4.6

Based on 1 reviews

Esoterica Books editorial team

Brower delivers a dense, academic exploration of French psychical research that demands patience from its audience. While intellectually stimulating for specialists in history of science or psychoanalytic studies, it may frustrate casual readers seeking narrative flair or accessible explanations of occult practices. The focus on the political and scientific mechanisms behind these investigations renders it dry for those expecting mystical revelations. It is strictly for those interested in the institutionalization of knowledge rather than the phenomena themselves. Do not expect light reading; this is a scholarly dissection of an intellectual crisis, suitable only for dedicated researchers willing to engage with complex historical dynamics.

❓ Frequently asked questions

No, the book primarily focuses on the *history* of scientific attempts to study these phenomena, not on proving or disproving their existence. It analyzes the methodologies, debates, and eventual limitations encountered by researchers.

While helpful, it's not strictly required. Brower provides ample context for the historical and scientific developments. The narrative is accessible, focusing on the intellectual journey and the personalities involved in this unique period of inquiry.

📖 Who should read this

🎯 Key themes and symbolism

Science Meets the Supernatural

This book delves into the fascinating friction between the burgeoning scientific method and the widespread belief in mediumship and parapsychic events. It showcases how 19th-century French researchers, initially skeptical, were compelled to confront and attempt to categorize phenomena that defied conventional understanding, highlighting the evolving boundaries of scientific inquiry.

Origins of French Psychoanalysis

Brower illuminates how the struggles of psychical researchers to explain intangible, subjective experiences created an intellectual vacuum. This inability to adequately address the complexities of the human mind through existing scientific models inadvertently prepared the ground for the eventual acceptance and integration of Freudian psychoanalytic theories into French academic thought.

Politics of Belief and Inquiry

The book reveals the significant role of political and cultural forces in shaping scientific pursuits. It illustrates how the French Third Republic, seeking to assert authority and rationalize public faith, legitimized the study of mediumism. This transformation saw popular spiritualism transition from a fringe belief to a subject deemed worthy of serious, institutionalized scientific investigation.

💬 Quotes from the book

“The institutionalization of psychical research in fin-de-siècle France was less about validating the supernatural and more about managing the perceived excesses of popular belief through empirical frameworks.”

“The eventual impasse in studying telepathy and materializations highlighted a critical limitation: the scientific method's struggle with interpersonal trust and unquantifiable subjective experiences.”

📜 Historical context

This work is situated within the rich tradition of exploring the mind's hidden depths and the nature of consciousness, a pursuit that intensified dramatically during the late 19th and early 20th centuries. It specifically contributes to understanding the pre-Freudian efforts to scientifically categorize and explain phenomena often relegated to mysticism, bridging the gap between spiritualism and nascent psychological science.

📚 Glossary

Epistemological crisis
Parapsychic phenomena
Mediumism

📔 Questions to reflect on

How might our current scientific understanding be limited by what we deem 'measurable,' and what phenomena are we perhaps overlooking as a result?
Reflect on how political or cultural anxieties in your own time might influence what scientific questions are prioritized or deemed legitimate for study.
Consider the tension between personal belief and scientific skepticism. Where do you draw the line, and how do you navigate phenomena that seem to defy conventional explanation?