What is this?: Ancient questions for modern minds

Martine Batchelor offers a compelling fusion of Korean Buddhist Sŏn retreats and modern existential challenges. The text effectively maps ancient methods onto contemporary scientific and philosophical frameworks, providing a robust framework for radical inquiry. However, this approach may not suit readers seeking traditional religious dogma or those who prefer straightforward spiritual advice over dense philosophical integration. It is best appreciated by those comfortable with abstract concepts and interdisciplinary synthesis. While intellectually stimulating, the lack of narrative plot might deter readers looking for a more conventional memoir style. Ultimately, it stands as a rigorous manual for the intellectually curious seeker.

Readers seeking a practical yet profound guide to navigating the complexities of modern existence will find immense value in this text. It is ideal for those interested in integrating ancient Sŏn inquiry with scientific understanding and Western philosophy. By engaging with Martine Batchelor’s insights, individuals can cultivate a fully engaged human experience that challenges conventional assumptions. This book serves as both a philosophical companion and a practical manual, offering tools to confront contemporary life with radical questioning. It appeals to those who wish to explore timeless wisdom without sacrificing intellectual rigor or poetic insight.

The Practice of Radical Inquiry

The Batchelors guide readers through the core Sŏn (Zen) practice of 'What is this?', an experiential method of inquiry that transcends intellectual understanding. This approach is presented not as a mere philosophical exercise, but as a dynamic tool for directly engaging with one's immediate experience and challenging preconceived notions of reality.

Bridging Ancient and Modern

This book masterfully demonstrates how a thousand-year-old Buddhist tradition can find profound resonance with contemporary thought. It draws unexpected connections between Sŏn's insights and findings in natural sciences, classical Western philosophy, the emotive power of Romantic poetry, and the foundational teachings of early Buddhism, creating a rich tapestry of understanding.

Living a Fully Human Life

Far from abstract theory, the teachings presented here are deeply rooted in the practical challenge of human existence. The authors offer a framework for using Sŏn inquiry as a means to respond skillfully and meaningfully to the complexities of modern life, empowering readers to confront their personal and societal challenges with clarity and presence.

“To truly face existence, we must first ask, without expectation, 'What is this?' and dwell in the open space of not knowing.”

“The ancient wisdom of Chan, when stripped of dogma, resonates deeply with the contemporary quest for meaning, finding echoes in both quantum physics and Romantic verse.”