US shipping Secure card payment Occult and esoteric books

Secrets of the Psychics: Investigating Paranormal Claims

Polidoro, Massimo
Reader rating
4.5
(5 reviews) 152 sold
Availability to be confirmed

This edition can be ordered. No arrival date is confirmed.

📚 ABOUT THE BOOK

Unmasking spiritualism’s great deceptions through forensic investigation and psychological insight.

Massimo Polidoro, a seasoned investigator with over fifteen years of experience, dissects the most notorious claims of the paranormal. He moves from historical sleight-of-hand, such as the Eusapia Palladino séances scrutinized by the Feilding Report and the Houdini-Doyle rivalry, to modern assertions of psychokinesis and healing. By exposing the mechanical tricks of Indian gurus and the psychological mechanisms behind psychic fraud, this volume offers a rigorous, evidence-based look at why we believe in the impossible. It is a masterclass in critical thinking disguised as a journey into the occult underworld.

Key themes
Skepticism and Evidence Historical Spiritualism Psychology of Deception
Historical context

This work sits firmly within the skeptical inquiry tradition of early twentieth-century spiritualism debates, bridging historical investigations with modern critical thinking. It serves as a contemporary counterpoint to occult literature by applying forensic rigor to paranormal claims.

Difficulty
●● Moderate
Fans will love it
James Randi · The Feilding Report · Carl Sagan's skeptical works
🕯️ Occult Philosophy
🏛 Prometheus Books 📖 302 pages 📔 Hardcover 📐 Hardcover ISBN: 9781591020868
Fun fact
Polidoro delivers a sharp, well-researched takedown of paranormal fraud that feels essential for any serious occult library. It excels in contextualizing historical cases like Palladino alongside modern myths. However, hardline believers may find its rationalism dismissive. It occupies a vital niche as a bridge between magic shop lore and scientific rigor, indispensable for those who value truth over illusion.
📚 This book appears in Esoterica Books

📝 Description: Secrets of the Psychics: Investigating Paranormal Claims

For more than fifteen years, Italian investigator Massimo Polidoro has examined dozens of supposedly paranormal events, some of them famous historical incidents, others contemporary claims of psychics, mediums, healers, "human magnets," a "girl with X-ray eyes," and the like. This fascinating book brings together the results of his investigations, presenting in-depth discussions of the evidence and the claims for each individual case. Among the historical events discussed are the Feilding Report on Eusapia Palladino, the most valued account of sEances performed by this famous medium; the relationship between renowned magician and skeptic Harry Houdini and mystery writer Arthur Conan Doyle, a firm believer in mediums and spiritualism; the case of Margery, the "blond witch of Lime Street"; and other equally strange happenings. Turning to contemporary paranormal claimants, Polidoro reveals the secrets of a Russian psychic; carefully examines demonstrations of psychokinesis; considers the evidence for some modern-day miracles; exposes the tricks of Indian gurus; and pursues many other interesting claims. In addition, he explores the psychology of psychic deception, considering mechanisms of deception and the unreliability of eyewitness testimony. This intriguing examination of the bizarre and the strange by a top-notch investigator will interest both skeptics and believers alike.

💎 Expert review

💎
Esoterica Books editorial team
Occult literature desk
Polidoro delivers a masterclass in skepticism, effectively unmasking spiritualism’s deceptions through detailed forensic analysis. While highly recommended for skeptics and rationalists seeking clarity on paranormal phenomena, this volume may frustrate devoted believers or those expecting validation of psychic abilities. It does not suit readers looking for mystical instruction or uncritical acceptance of supernatural claims. However, for those willing to engage with hard evidence and historical scrutiny, it offers a compelling, intellectually stimulating journey that demystifies the occult underworld without resorting to condescension, making it a robust addition to any critical library.
✓ EDITOR'S REVIEW

📖 Why choose it

📖

Why this book is worth reading

This book is essential for anyone fascinated by the occult but wary of deception, offering a rigorous yet accessible dissection of paranormal claims. Readers who enjoy historical mysteries or psychological insights will appreciate how Polidoro unravels the mechanical tricks of Indian gurus and the sleight-of-hand behind famous séances. It provides intellectual satisfaction for those seeking evidence-based explanations for why we believe in the impossible. By combining forensic investigation with psychological insight, it empowers readers to distinguish between genuine mystery and calculated fraud, making it a valuable tool for cultivating critical thinking skills within the context of esoteric traditions.

⭐ Reader reviews

The starting rating comes from the team Esoterica Books —
⭐ Esoterica editorial review Editorial rating 4.6/5
★★★★
Readers fascinated by the intersection of magic and science, skeptics seeking robust arguments against pseudoscience, and occultists who appreciate the craft behind the curtain rather than just the illusion.

Reader rating

4.5
Based on 5 reviews
5
2
4
3
3
0
2
0
1
0
E
Edmund M.
April 18, 2026
Exceeded expectations

Bought this as a gift for my sister and ended up ordering a second copy for myself. Challenging in places, but never needlessly obscure. It pairs well with more modern commentaries on the same tradition. Recommended if you're ready to do the work.

E
Edmund L.
July 10, 2025

I keep coming back to this one. You can tell why this work has endured.

A
Andrew A. ✓ Verified purchase
July 16, 2025
Solid edition

Bought this as a gift for my sister and ended up ordering a second copy for myself. Not a light read, but far more accessible than I feared. Every rereading turns up something I missed. A few pages arrived with light corner wear, though nothing serious. Good, with the caveats above.

J
Jessica V. ✓ Verified purchase
January 3, 2025
Almost perfect

Took a chance on this and glad I did. The ideas are old but land with surprising force today. It rewards patience more than any book I've bought this year. The font runs small in the appendices. Solid, if not essential.

E
Esoterica Books editorial team

Polidoro delivers a masterclass in skepticism, effectively unmasking spiritualism’s deceptions through detailed forensic analysis. While highly recommended for skeptics and rationalists seeking clarity on paranormal phenomena, this volume may frustrate devoted believers or those expecting validation of psychic abilities. It does not suit readers looking for mystical instruction or uncritical acceptance of supernatural claims. However, for those willing to engage with hard evidence and historical scrutiny, it offers a compelling, intellectually stimulating journey that demystifies the occult underworld without resorting to condescension, making it a robust addition to any critical library.

❓ Frequently asked questions

It does not claim to disprove the unknown, but rather exposes the specific tricks, psychological biases, and fraudulent methods used by claimants to fabricate their powers.
No, Polidoro approaches the subject with intellectual curiosity, focusing on the mechanics of the deception and the fascinating history of the claims rather than mocking the believers.

📖 Who should read this

Readers fascinated by the intersection of magic and science, skeptics seeking robust arguments against pseudoscience, and occultists who appreciate the craft behind the curtain rather than just the illusion.

🎯 Key themes and symbolism

Skepticism and Evidence

Historical Spiritualism

Psychology of Deception

💬 Quotes from the book

“The line between miracle and trick is often drawn by the presence of an audience and the absence of control.”

“We see what we wish to see, not what is actually there.”

📜 Historical context

Polidoro’s work sits firmly within the tradition of scientific skepticism established by figures like Houdini and the Society for Psychical Research. It bridges the gap between the Victorian fascination with spiritualism and the modern demand for empirical proof, continuing the legacy of investigative journalism that challenges the supernatural with rational inquiry.

📚 Glossary

Feilding Report
Psychokinesis
Human Magnetism

📔 Questions to reflect on

  1. When have you accepted a claim without verifying the source or method?
  2. What emotional need might drive someone to believe in psychic abilities?
  3. How does the context of a performance change the interpretation of its events?

🏛 Books from this publisher Prometheus Books

All books from this publisher →

You might also like

See more →